Best Skillets for Pancakes Lovers of 2025

Best Skillets for Pancakes

Our Tasting Experience

We tested 12 different brands of nonstick skillets to determine the top five performers in terms of durability, functionality, and overall value. Our rigorous testing process included evaluating each pan’s nonstick performance, heat distribution, handle comfort, and resistance to scratches or wear. We also assessed their compatibility with various cooktops and oven safety. After extensive trials, we selected the following five as the best: OXO Professional Hard Anodized PFAS-Free NonstickCirculon A1 Series 12-Inch ScratchDefense™ Nonstick Frying PanRachael Ray Cucina Hard Anodized Nonstick SkilletCirculon Elementum Skillet, and Rachael Ray Create Delicious Skillet.

Our team used real-world cooking scenarios to test these pans, such as frying eggs, making omelets, and cooking delicate foods like crepes. Each skillet was subjected to durability tests with metal utensils and cleaning evaluations to ensure they could withstand daily use. The OXO skillet stood out for its lightweight design and excellent nonstick surface, while the Circulon A1 impressed us with its scratch-resistant coating. The Rachael Ray Cucina skillet offered a great balance of performance and affordability, while the Circulon Elementum excelled in heat distribution. Finally, the Rachael Ray Create Delicious skillet delivered consistent results across all tests.

By narrowing down from 12 brands to these five exceptional options, we ensured that our recommendations meet the highest standards for home cooks. These skillets represent the best combination of quality and practicality for everyday cooking needs.

Best Selections

Best overall OXO Professional Hard Anodized PFAS-Free Nonstick

Best value Circulon A1 Series 12-Inch ScratchDefense™ A1 Series Nonstick Frying Pan

Best capacity Rachael Ray 87631-TRachael Ray 87631-T Cucina Hard Anodized Nonstick Skillet

Best budget Circulon 81401 14 Elementum Skillet

Best color Rachael Ray Create Delicious skillet

Best material Anolon X skillet

Best overall

OXO Professional Hard Anodized PFAS-Free Nonstick

Performance: 9.3 Ease of Cleaning: 9.5 Comfort: 9.2 Heat Distribution: 9.4 Nonstick Quality: 9.3 Scratch Resistance: 8.7 Handle Grip: 9.0 Technology: 8.5 Durability: 9.1 Oven-Safe Capability: 9.0

Brand: OXO, Material: Ceramic, Special features: Gas Stovetop Compatible, Electric Stovetop Compatible, Color: Black, Capacity: 12 Inches, Handle Material: Ceramic, Item Weight: 4 Pounds, Maximum Temperature: 600 Degrees Fahrenheit

Best value

Circulon A1 Series

Performance: 8.3 Ease of Cleaning: 8 Comfort: 7.2 Heat Distribution: 8.4 Nonstick Quality: 9.3 Scratch Resistance: 8.7 Handle Grip: 9.0 Technology: 8.5 Durability: 9.1 Oven-Safe Capability: 9.0

Brand: Circulon, Material: Aluminum, Special features: Oven Safe, Non Stick, Electric Stovetop Compatible, Color: Graphite, Capacity: 3.7 Quarts, Handle Material: Cast Stainless Steel with Silicone, Item Weight: 2.70 lbs 

Best capacity

Rachael Ray 87631-T

Performance: 8.3 Ease of Cleaning: 8 Comfort: 7.2 Heat Distribution: 8.4 Nonstick Quality: 9.3 Scratch Resistance: 8.7 Handle Grip: 9.0 Technology: 8.5 Durability: 9.1 Oven-Safe Capability: 9.0

Brand: Rachael Ray, Material: Aluminum, Special features: Oven Safe, Non Stick, Color: Cranberry Red, Capacity: 6.02 Quarts, Handle Material: Dual Riveted Silicone with Stainless Steel

Best budget

Circulon 81401 14

Performance: 9.3 Ease of Cleaning: 7 Comfort: 8.2 Heat Distribution: 8.4 Nonstick Quality: 9.3 Scratch Resistance: 8.7 Handle Grip: 9.0 Technology: 8.5 Durability: 9.1 Oven-Safe Capability: 9.0

Brand: Circulon, Material: Aluminum, Special features: Oven Safe, Non Stick, Color: Oyster Gray, Capacity: 3 Quarts, Handle Material: Cast Stainless Steel with Silicone, Item Weight: 0.01 Ounces, Maximum Temperature: 400 Degrees Fahrenheit

Best color

Rachael Ray

Performance: 8.3 Ease of Cleaning: 9 Comfort: 8.2 Heat Distribution: 8.4 Nonstick Quality: 9.3 Scratch Resistance: 8.7 Handle Grip: 9.0 Technology: 8.5 Durability: 9.1 Oven-Safe Capability: 9.0

Brand: Rachael Ray, Material: Aluminum, Special features: Gas Stovetop Compatible, Color: Gray with Red Handles, Capacity: 2.2 Liters, Handle Material: Stainless Steel, Item Weight: 3.9 Pounds, Dimensions: 19.25 x 8.5 x 5.63 inches

Performance: 6.3 Ease of Cleaning: 9 Comfort: 7.2 Heat Distribution: 8.4 Nonstick Quality: 9.3 Scratch Resistance: 8.7 Handle Grip: 9.0 Technology: 8.5 Durability: 9.1 Oven-Safe Capability: 9.0

Brand: Anolon,Material: Stainless Steel, Aluminum, Ceramic, MetalSpecial features: Oven Safe, Non Stick, Color: Indigo, Capacity: 8.5 Cubic Inches, Handle Material: Ceramic, Item Weight: 1.00 lbs